Pipe Stress 103 – How to Spot Pipe Stress Problems in Your Facility

This is the third article in a series of articles about thermal stress, pipe stress and the art of pipe stress analysis.  The first article provided a look at what is thermal expansion and contraction, and an idea of the magnitude of thermal growth you could expect to see from a hot pipe. In the second article we took a closer look at the importance of proper stress analysis and good engineering practice to offset the risks that thermal expansion poses to piping and equipment.

Unmitigated thermal expansion and pipe stress issues can result in pipe or equipment damage, maintenance issues or even pipe ruptures. This article covers signs of potential thermal growth or stress issues you can spot while walking around your facility. A future article will focus on less obvious indications or signs that might require you to consult the piping and instrumentation diagram (P&IDs) and isometrics of your system.

While out in your facility pay attention to the following items. Each of these could be a sign that pipe stress issues due to thermal expansion or contraction are wreaking havoc in your piping system. While these signs are not absolute proof, they can be a good indication that a particular piping system may need a closer look.

Bent or “Squirming” Straight Pipe

This most often happens when a relatively long run of pipe has grown thermally but is bound in the axial direction at both ends; the resulting force bends the pipe. In very long runs of pipe, or runs of piping with an expansion joint, you may see this as “squirming” of the pipe.

Thermal-Expansion
Figure 1 – Bent Piping from Thermal Expansion
(“Walraven USA”, 00:00:48-00:00:58)

Bent Elbows

Another common place to see an excessive bending is at a piping elbow. Pay attention to elbows that seem extended too far (bent to an angle greater than 90 degrees) or compressed too far (bent to an angle less than 90 degrees). If the bare pipe is visible, further indication that the pipe may have bent from a 90-degree angle (as opposed to a piping elbow trimmed to a different angle) and is out-of-roundness in the elbow curve is known as ovalization. For elbows that have been compressed, the ovalization will typically be perpendicular to the direction of compression. For elbows that have been extended, the ovalization will typically be in the same plane as the extension.

Bent Pipe
Figure 2 – Model Results from a Bent Pipe (ASME Digital Collection)

Bent or Cracked Nozzles

Bent nozzles on equipment are another sure sign that thermal expansion and pipe stress may be causing problems in your system. Typically, these signs will be seen on tanks and pressure vessels with thinner walls. This might also show up as a distortion in the shell around the nozzle, in these cases. It’s rare to see a bent nozzle on a piece of rotating equipment, but if this is seen, it could indicate a severe overloading of the nozzle.

Thermal Expansion
Figure 3 – Bent/Broken Pressure Vessel Nozzle
(© Werner Sölken)

Leaking Flanges

Leaking flanges can have many causes, including improper bolt tightening, over pressure and gasket failure. While leaking flanges may not be directly related to thermal growth or pipe stress issues, a poorly designed piping system can allow excessive lateral or bending forces to negatively impact a flange, resulting in leaks. If you see a leaking flange take note and look for other potential signs of excessive thermal stress, especially if this particular flange is a repeat offender.

Leaking Flange
Figure 4 – Leaking Flange
(NESS Wärmetechnik GmbH)

Pipe Support Issues

Pipe supports are meant to support the weight of the pipe and, in some cases, direct the movement of the pipe or restrict excessive movement. Pipe shoes that have lifted or slid off support structures may indicate thermal growth and stress issues.

Shoe Lifting
Figure 5 – Pipe Shoe Lifting off Support (SlideServe.com)
Pipe Shoe Off Steel
Figure 6 – Pipe Shoe Off Steel (Amarineblog.com)

Pipe shoes, guides and line stop lugs or supporting steel that have been bent, broken or otherwise damaged are prime indicators that an unexpected force has affected the pipe.  Keep in mind the damage doesn’t have to be limited to the support and could be noted as a bend or dent in the pipe at the point of attachment.  These damages could result from water hammer, excessive thermal growth, high expansion joint loads or some other external force like high winds or a seismic event. All of these indicate that further investigation may be warranted.

Bent Pipe Shoe
Figure 7 – Bent Pipe Shoe (Slideshare.net)

Bent Support Steel or Rod Hangers

These could indicate a large thermal movement or thermal stress that was not adequately designed for. While it’s not uncommon to see rod hangers that are tilted (as opposed to obviously bent) due to small axial or lateral movements of the pipe, bent rods or significant movement can indicate problems you need to address.

Bent Rod Hangers
Figure 8 – Bent Rod Hangers (Slideshare.net)
Laterally Bent Rod Hanger
Figure 9 – Laterally Bent Rod Hanger

Excessive Vibration

Piping up or downstream from rotating or reciprocating equipment that has visible or excessive vibration can indicate either excessive pipe stress or insufficient piping support. Remember, not all pipe stress issues are caused by thermal growth. Piping that is not adequately supported and results in excessive loading on an equipment nozzle (as potentially indicated by excessive vibration) is also a pipe stress issue.

Spring Hangers

Variable spring hangers and constant support hangers are designed specifically to support pipes that move during operating. In most cases this movement will be from thermal expansion or the thermal expansion of an attached piece of equipment (or a combination of the two). There are a couple of easy-to-spot things with a spring hanger that might indicate an issue with the thermal growth of the system.

First, the spring hanger or hanger assembly should remain nearly vertical. The rod hanger attached to a spring (or the whole assembly if the spring is hung in line with the rod) should be no more than 4 degrees from vertical in the cold or hot position.

Spring Support with Excessive Tilt
Figure 10 – Spring Support with Excessive Tilt (Slideshare.net)

The second indication of a problem is the spring hanger that is bottomed or topped out. Most spring hangers will have an indicator showing the relative position of the spring in relation to the maximum travel allowed for the specific hanger. Usually both the hot and cold positions are clearly indicated. If the indicator is outside of the cold-to-hot range, this can indicate trouble; seeing a spring hanger completely at the top or bottom of its range is a much stronger indication of problems.

Bottomed or Topped out Spring Hangers
Figure 11 – Bottomed or Topped out Spring Hangers (insights.globalspec.com)

Keeping an eye out for these kinds of indications can alert you to the possibility of excessive or unplanned for thermal growth, resulting in pipe stress problems. Remember that not all pipe stress issues are thermal in nature, so keep an eye out for excessive vibration or unexplained pipe movement as indicated by bent or off steel shoes.

In the next article, we will dig into some of the more subtle signs that a facility may have unmitigated pipe stress problems to address, or perhaps your plant might benefit from a more comprehensive Pipe Stress Audit. Check back with us to see what the signs are.

Matrix Technologies is one of the largest independent process design, industrial automation engineering, and manufacturing operations management companies in North America. To learn more about thermal expansion and pipe stress analysis, contact Chris Mach, Senior Consultant or Brandon Grodi, Mechanical Department Manager.

© Matrix Technologies, Inc.

Tags: Oil & Gas / Pipe Stress / Piping Engineer / Process Engineer / Stress Analysis / Thermal Contraction / Construction / Manufacturing /

Get Our Newsletter

Can We Help You?

Matrix engineers can find solutions for your process and facility design, industrial automation engineering, and manufacturing operations management challenges.Contact Us